Hibs and Hearts battled out a second Scottish Premiership goalless draw of the season in a breathless Edinburgh derby at Easter Road.
Debutant goalkeeper Kevin Dabrowski was the home hero, making three second-half saves to deny Ellis Simms.
Hibs nearly snatched it at the death, with Tony Sibbick making a goal-line clearance from a Josh Campbell shot.
Third-placed Hearts, who had two strong penalty claims, stay 12 points clear of their city rivals in fifth.
September’s stalemate at Tynecastle was a higher-quality affair, with chances galore and both goalkeepers on top form that day.
But this was a night to remember for Dabrowski, with the 23-year-old stepping in for the injured Matt Macey and giving a very good account of himself.
The keeper’s last senior game came on loan at Dumbarton in December 2020 when he let in four against Montrose.
Dabrowski was perhaps lucky to escape when he pushed out a first-half strike from Liam Boyce but Simms could only head his follow-up over the top.
As Hearts took a grip on the game after the interval, Simms had two near-post shots kept out by the goalkeeper after the best stop, a spreading block with his chest when the Hearts striker was clean through.
“I’ve been waiting for this moment all my life,” said the Polish keeper. “It’s taken me five years at this club to get ready. This place is like a second home – they gave me character and made me a man.”
Dabrowski was at the centre of more drama on 85 minutes when he dived to save a backpass from Rocky Bushiri, his quick-thinking preventing a calamitous own goal.
The indirect free-kick was charged down, with the ball striking both arms of Lewis Stevenson, the first of the defenders to come sprinting out of the wall.
Stevenson, Hibs captain in place of the injured Paul Hanlon, was involved in another penalty claim in the first half when he floored Simms.
Hearts boss Robbie Neilson was flabbergasted that Stevenson, already on a booking, was not sent off for the incident, which he said “99.9% of television viewers would agree was a penalty and a red card”.
Neilson’s side are now unbeaten in five visits to Easter Road, while there hasn’t been a home win in the past nine fixtures.
That could all have changed in the dying moments when Ewan Henderson nodded a Chris Cadden cross back into the path of fellow substitute Josh Campbell, who crashed a shot beyond Craig Gordon, only to see it strike the legs of defender Sibbick.
The newly arrived Hearts defender also saved what looked like a certain goal in the first half when he got the slightest touch on a Chris Mueller cross to deceive the waiting Christian Doidge.
Hibs, without a win in four Premiership outings, had started well with Kevin Nisbet twice offside when he poked a close-range shot against the post, and when Hearts’ Taylor Moore diverted a Ryan Porteous header into his own net.
Man of the match – Kevin Dabrowski
What did we learn?
Hibs fans had been growing restless with the ponderous approach under Shaun Maloney as players adapt to the new manager’s focus on possession, but there was much more intensity and aggression on show against their city rivals.
Ryan Porteous and Bushiri led by example with wholehearted defending, but there remains a lack of penetration in the final third in the absence of the recently departed Martin Boyle.
Hearts will feel sore about the two penalty claims, but a share of the spoils keeps the rest at bay as they remain in pole position to finish third on their return to the top flight.
Sibbick, who hadn’t played since November, stepped in to replace the injured John Souttar and can be very pleased with his second debut for the club as he suggested he can fill the considerable gap that will be left when the Scotland defender joins Rangers at the end of the season.
What did they say?
Hibernian manager Shaun Maloney: “I loved it. I thought it was a great game. As it went on, it felt like we had more chances but the momentum swung both ways and that’s what you expect in derbies.
“Kevin Dabrowski was incredible and he should really enjoy tonight.
“I want the players to play as much as possible but you have to adapt and the pitch is not the easiest. It’s going to take time to implement what I’m asking them to do, but I’m super-proud of what they gave me.”
Hearts manager Robbie Neilson: “The first one [penalty appeal] is a stonewaller. The second one, I can understand a wee bit. The referee said it struck his hand but he thought it was close to the body. I differ in that opinion.
“I think we need VAR. If we had it, we get two penalties. It is what it is, but there is still a responsibility to get key decisions right when it’s as blatant as that.”
What next?
Hibs have a third successive home game on Saturday, with St Mirren the visitors (15:00 GMT), before Hearts visit Rangers on Sunday (16:00).
Player of the match
SimmsEllis Simms
Hibernian
-
Squad number21Player nameDabrowskiAverage rating
6.57
-
Squad number5Player namePorteousAverage rating
6.15
-
Squad number27Player nameCadden
Average rating6.10
-
Squad number16Player nameStevenson
Average rating5.84
-
Squad number80Player nameHenderson
Average rating5.75
-
Squad number33Player nameBushiri
Average rating5.71
-
Squad number3Player nameDoig
Average rating5.60
-
Squad number32Player nameCampbell
Average rating5.51
-
Squad number22Player nameDoyle-Hayes
Average rating5.43
-
Squad number14Player nameMueller
Average rating5.36
-
Squad number19Player nameMitchell
Average rating5.33
-
Squad number9Player nameDoidge
Average rating5.19
-
Squad number15Player nameNisbet
Average rating5.00
-
Squad number11Player nameNewell
Average rating4.69
-
Squad number8Player nameWright
Average rating4.59
Heart of Midlothian
-
Squad number20Player nameSimms
Average rating7.57
-
Squad number21Player nameSibbick
Average rating7.56
-
Squad number3Player nameKingsley
Average rating7.52
-
Squad number12Player nameAtkinson
Average rating7.33
-
Squad number6Player nameBaningime
Average rating7.29
-
Squad number10Player nameBoyce
Average rating7.09
-
Squad number14Player nameDevlin
Average rating7.03
-
Squad number18Player nameMcKay
Average rating7.02
-
Squad number15Player nameMoore
Average rating6.96
-
Squad number16Player nameHalliday
Average rating6.77
-
Squad number1Player nameGordon
Average rating6.70
-
Squad number17Player nameCochrane
Average rating5.89
-
Squad number30Player nameGinnelly
Average rating5.64
-
Squad number5Player nameHaring
Average rating5.62
-
Squad number9Player nameWoodburn
Average rating5.37
Line-ups
Hibernian
Formation 3-4-1-2
- 21Dabrowski
- 33Bushiri
- 5Porteous
- 16StevensonBooked at 11mins
- 27Cadden
- 22Doyle-Hayes
- 11NewellBooked at 58minsSubstituted forCampbellat 69′minutes
- 3DoigSubstituted forMitchellat 45′minutes
- 14MuellerSubstituted forWrightat 60′minutes
- 15Nisbet
- 9DoidgeSubstituted forHendersonat 79′minutes
Substitutes
- 8Wright
- 19Mitchell
- 20Jasper
- 23Allan
- 24McGregor
- 25Scott
- 31Mitchell
- 32Campbell
- 80Henderson
Hearts
Formation 3-4-1-2
- 1Gordon
- 15MooreBooked at 12mins
- 21Sibbick
- 3Kingsley
- 12Atkinson
- 14DevlinBooked at 45minsSubstituted forHaringat 90+2′minutes
- 6Baningime
- 16HallidayBooked at 17minsSubstituted forCochraneat 69′minutes
- 18McKaySubstituted forWoodburnat 68′minutes
- 20Simms
- 10BoyceSubstituted forGinnellyat 80′minutes
Substitutes
- 5Haring
- 8McEneff
- 9Woodburn
- 11Mackay-Steven
- 13Stewart
- 17Cochrane
- 22Henderson
- 30Ginnelly
- 38Pollock
- Referee:
- Don Robertson
- Attendance:
- 20,419
Match Stats
Live Text
-
Match ends, Hibernian 0, Heart of Midlothian 0.
-
Second Half ends, Hibernian 0, Heart of Midlothian 0.
-
Foul by Ben Woodburn (Heart of Midlothian).
-
Ryan Porteous (Hibernian) wins a free kick in the attacking half.
-
Foul by Ben Woodburn (Heart of Midlothian).
-
Ryan Porteous (Hibernian) wins a free kick in the defensive half.
-
Substitution, Heart of Midlothian. Peter Haring replaces Cameron Devlin because of an injury.
-
Nathaniel Atkinson (Heart of Midlothian) wins a free kick in the defensive half.
-
Foul by Ewan Henderson (Hibernian).
-
Attempt missed. Kevin Nisbet (Hibernian) right footed shot from the centre of the box is too high.
-
Attempt blocked. Josh Campbell (Hibernian) left footed shot from the centre of the box is blocked. Assisted by Ewan Henderson with a headed pass.
-
Attempt blocked. Josh Ginnelly (Heart of Midlothian) right footed shot from outside the box is blocked. Assisted by Alex Cochrane.
-
Attempt blocked. Alex Cochrane (Heart of Midlothian) left footed shot from the centre of the box is blocked. Assisted by Ben Woodburn.
-
(Heart of Midlothian) wins a free kick in the attacking half.
-
Back pass by Maciej Dabrowski (Hibernian).
-
Attempt blocked. Kevin Nisbet (Hibernian) right footed shot from the left side of the box is blocked. Assisted by Josh Campbell.
-
Attempt saved. Ewan Henderson (Hibernian) right footed shot from outside the box is saved in the centre of the goal. Assisted by Kevin Nisbet.
-
Foul by Ellis Simms (Heart of Midlothian).
-
Ryan Porteous (Hibernian) wins a free kick in the defensive half.
-
Offside, Heart of Midlothian. Ben Woodburn tries a through ball, but Josh Ginnelly is caught offside.